How to remove a broken bathtub drain stopper?

 
Preparation and Safety Measures
 

• Gather necessary tools such as a screwdriver (flathead and/or Phillips depending on your drain stopper type), pliers, a utility knife, a drain removal wrench if available, and a cloth or rag.
• Wear safety glasses and gloves to protect your eyes and hands from sharp edges or any lodged debris.
• Clear the bathtub of any items and place an old towel or cloth nearby to protect the tub surface from scratches.

 
Identify the Stopper Type
 

• Observe your bathtub drain stopper to determine if it is a lift-and-turn, push-and-pull, or a plunger style stopper. The removal technique might slightly vary depending on the type.
• If the stopper is broken, look for remaining parts, such as the pivot rod or screws that might still be attached to the tub’s overflow plate.

 
Detach the Stopper from the Overflow Plate
 

• Locate the overflow plate behind the drain stopper. Depending on your tub model, it may be secured with screws or clips.
• If screws are present, use the appropriate screwdriver to remove them carefully and take off the overflow plate.
• Examine the stopper mechanism connected to the overflow plate. Sometimes, the stopper is linked to a metal or plastic rod that is mechanically attached, and even if the stopper is broken, the rod must be detached.

 
Disconnect the Mechanism Inside the Drain
 

• With the overflow plate removed, you will see the connecting rod or mechanism that holds the stopper. Use pliers to grasp the rod firmly. If necessary, wiggle gently to free it from any corrosion or debris.
• If the stopper is stuck with glue or suction, carefully use a utility knife to cut through any remaining sealant or debris around the mechanism.
• Check if the rod or operating mechanism is corroded or broken; note that some parts could be damaged and may require replacement once the stopper is removed.

 
Remove the Broken Stopper Itself
 

• After the mechanism has been disconnected from the overflow assembly, grasp the broken parts of the stopper. Use pliers to pull it out of the drain if it is still lodged in place.
• If the stopper is stuck inside the drain, gently twist and pull it. Avoid using excessive force which could damage the drain or the tub finish.
• If there's any obstruction, use a drain removal tool or even a bent wire hanger to help free the remaining parts from the drain pipe.

 
Clean the Drain Area
 

• Once the stopper and any related parts are removed, clear out any debris, broken fragments, or corrosion from the drain area.
• If needed, use a small brush and drain cleaner to clear out any remaining grime or mineral buildup inside and around the drain opening.
• Wipe down the area avoiding harsh chemicals that could damage the tub surface.

 
Installation of a New Drain Stopper
 

• Before installing a new stopper, ensure you have the correct replacement part that is compatible with your bathtub model.
• Follow the manufacturer’s instructions precisely. Typically, reinstall the connecting rod to the overflow assembly first and then attach the new stopper.
• Secure all screws or clips firmly. Test the stopper operation by filling the tub with a little water and engaging the stopper to ensure a proper seal.

 
Final Checks and Troubleshooting
 

• Double-check all connections to ensure there are no loose parts or remaining pieces from the broken stopper.
• Inspect for any leaks around the drain area once the new stopper is installed.
• If any issues persist such as improper sealing or mechanical problems, re-inspect the installation steps or consult a professional plumber for further advice.

 

Many homeowners and businesses – including some from St. Louis and Nashville – have found these guidelines useful for maintaining a well-functioning drainage system.